Home / Home & cleaning / Mattresses / Compare
Casper Original vs Tuft & Needle Original
The Tuft & Needle Original comes out ahead for most homes.
The verdict in 10 seconds
The Casper Original suits you if
- You share the bed with a restless partner and want to sleep undisturbed
- You sleep on your back or switch positions and are of average build
- You like a responsive foam feel rather than a slow, sinking one
May not suit you if
- You sleep hot or often sit and sleep near the edge of the bed
- You're a heavier sleeper or sleep mainly on your stomach
- You're sensitive to new-mattress smells that can take a while to fade
The Tuft & Needle Original suits you if
- You share a bed with a restless partner or pet
- You sleep mostly on your back and are light to average weight
- You want a comfortable foam bed on a budget, or one for a guest room
May not suit you if
- You're a heavier sleeper who needs firm, deep support
- You often sit on or sleep near the edge of the bed
- You sleep very hot and want a bed that feels cool to the touch
The short version
The Tuft & Needle Original is the stronger all-rounder of the two. The Casper Original is still the better fit if you share the bed with a restless partner and want to sleep undisturbed.
We researched 18 expert reviews, analyzed 105,374 owner ratings and comments across 16 sources for the two, and cross-checked them into one verdict, so you don't have to.
See the evidence
The scoreboardProduct Review score 66 vs 81 · reliability 74 vs 86
| Casper Original | Tuft & Needle Original | |
|---|---|---|
| Product Review score | 66 | 81 |
| Experts | 74 | 75 |
| Owners | 55 | 84 |
| Reliability | 74 | 86 |
| Report problems | 11% | 5% |
| Evidence | 9 reviews · 357 comments | 9 reviews · 454 comments |
| Typical price | $874–$1,695 | $895–$995 |
● marks the better number on each row.
Experts vs ownersExperts 74 vs 75 · Owners 55 vs 84
Casper Original
Tuft & Needle Original
How we reached each verdictThe numbers behind each model's score
Casper Original
Experts like the Casper Original more than owners do: it scores 74 with experts but 55 with owners, for a medium-confidence overall 66. Motion isolation is the clearest strength, praised by 7 of 8 hands-on reviewers, while 6 of 8 call edge support average to very poor and most say it sleeps warm. Among 357 owner comments, half praise comfort and 21% praise support, but 8% cite poor customer service, 7% mention sagging, and 11% mention some kind of failure. The evidence on firmness is thin and contradictory, and several reviewers note it has been replaced by the Casper One, so long-term availability is uncertain.
Tuft & Needle Original
All nine expert sources tested this mattress hands-on, though Consumer Reports' results are paywalled and Wired reviewed the Hybrid version, so the expert picture really rests on seven to eight reviews. Owners are notably positive: of 454 comments (438 first-hand), 62% praise comfort and 23% praise support, while only 5% mention sagging and 9% say it's too soft. Experts agree on strong motion isolation and value but flag weak edge support in 6 of 8 visible reviews, and 5 caution heavier sleepers. Durability evidence is thin and conflicting, with one source estimating only five to six years of life and another calling the foam densities durable.
Where each one falls shortThe most common complaints
Casper Original
- Weak edge support that sinks when sitting
- Sleeps warm for some people
- Off-gassing smell and mixed customer service reputation
Tuft & Needle Original
- Weak edges that sink when you sit on the side
- Can sleep warm for hot sleepers
- Too soft and unsupportive for heavier people
Quick answers
Which is better, the Casper Original or the Tuft & Needle Original?
The Tuft & Needle Original, for most homes. The Casper Original is the better fit if you share the bed with a restless partner and want to sleep undisturbed.
Based on: Product Review score 66 vs 81.Which is more reliable?
The Tuft & Needle Original. It's the least likely of the two to give you trouble.
Based on: Reliability 74 vs 86; problems mentioned by 11% vs 5% of owners.Which is easier to live with day to day?
The Tuft & Needle Original. It's the one people are happiest with once it's home.
Based on: Owners score 55 vs 84, from ratings and comments.Which is cheaper?
The Casper Original usually costs less.
Based on: Typical prices: Casper Original $874–$1,695; Tuft & Needle Original $895–$995.As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. It never changes a score.