Home / Home & cleaning / Pillows / Compare
Brooklinen Down Pillow vs MyPillow
The Brooklinen Down Pillow comes out ahead for most homes.
The verdict in 10 seconds
The Brooklinen Down Pillow suits you if
- You love a soft, sink-in, hotel-style down feel
- You want to choose a firmness that matches how you sleep
- You don't mind giving your pillow a quick fluff to restore its loft
Skip it if
- You need firm, structured support for neck problems
- You sleep hot and want a pillow that feels cool
- You're vegan, allergic to down, or want an easy toss-in-the-wash pillow
The MyPillow suits you if
- You sleep on your stomach and like a thin, soft pillow
- You want a pillow you can throw in the washer and dryer
- You like to fold, scrunch, and shape your pillow
Skip it if
- You need steady, even support that won't shift overnight
- You don't want to fluff your pillow in the dryer often
- You sleep hot and want a cooling pillow
So, which one?
The Brooklinen Down Pillow is the stronger all-rounder of the two. The MyPillow is still the better fit if you sleep on your stomach and like a thin, soft pillow.
We researched 11 expert reviews, analyzed 15,896 owner ratings and comments across 13 sources for the two, and cross-checked them into one verdict, so you don't have to.
Show me the receipts
The scoreboardProduct Review score 70 vs 58 · reliability 38 vs 68
| Brooklinen Down Pillow | MyPillow | |
|---|---|---|
| Product Review score | 70 | 58 |
| Experts | 85 | 44 |
| Owners | 71 | 67 |
| Reliability | 38 | 68 |
| Report problems | 25% | 13% |
| Evidence | 6 reviews · 463 comments | 5 reviews · 78 comments |
| Typical price | $79–$149 | $20–$80 |
● marks the better number on each row.
Experts vs ownersExperts 85 vs 44 · Owners 71 vs 67
Brooklinen Down Pillow
MyPillow
How we reached each verdictThe numbers behind each model's score
Brooklinen Down Pillow
Our research found strong expert approval: all 6 hands-on expert sources we analyzed praise its soft, cloud-like comfort, giving an expert score of 85. Across 463 owner comments (405 first-hand), 46% praise comfort and 18% praise support, but 20% say it flattens, 13% find it too soft and 10% too firm, and 25% mention some kind of failure, which drags the reliability score down to 38. Neck support is its weakest point: one expert called it not great for neck support, and 8% of owner comments mention worse neck pain. Evidence is mixed on care and warranty, with expert sources split on whether it's machine washable and on whether the warranty runs one or two years.
MyPillow
Our research found a wide gap between owners and hands-on testers: owner sentiment scores 67 while expert assessment scores just 44, giving an overall 58 with low confidence. Among the 78 owner comments we analyzed, 45% praise comfort and 17% praise support, but 15% describe it as lumpy and 10% feel it is poor value. Of the 4 hands-on tests, three with published findings flagged lumpy or uneven fill and two advised against it as a main pillow, while the one positive verdict came from a non-hands-on assessment. Evidence is thin: one hands-on lab result is unavailable, and only 2 owners specifically mention neck pain.
Where each one falls shortThe most common complaints
Brooklinen Down Pillow
- Flattens over time and needs regular fluffing
- Not firm or supportive enough for some, including neck pain sufferers
- Down smell at first and sleeps somewhat warm
MyPillow
- Lumpy, clumping shredded-foam fill
- Flattens and compresses over time
- Price feels high for the quality
Questions people actually ask
Which is better, the Brooklinen Down Pillow or the MyPillow?
The Brooklinen Down Pillow, for most homes. The MyPillow is the better fit if you sleep on your stomach and like a thin, soft pillow.
Based on: Product Review score 70 vs 58.Which is more reliable?
The MyPillow. It's the least likely of the two to give you trouble.
Based on: Reliability 38 vs 68; problems mentioned by 25% vs 13% of owners.Which is easier to live with day to day?
The Brooklinen Down Pillow. It's the one people are happiest with once it's home.
Based on: Owners score 71 vs 67, from ratings and comments.Which is cheaper?
The MyPillow usually costs less.
Based on: Typical prices: Brooklinen Down Pillow $79–$149; MyPillow $20–$80.As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. It never changes a score.